Payton Krueger

Coldwell Banker Real Estate Group
1050 North Lynndale Drive, Appleton, WI 54914


Cell: 920-585-3211

Visit My Website

Markets Served: Appleton, WI;Waupaca, Wisconsin;Kimberly, Wisconsin;Neenah, Wisconsin;Oshkosh, Wisconsin;

Specialties: Buyer's Specialist; Co-ops/Condos; College Communities; Country Properties; Custom Construction; Downtown; Equestrian; Executive Relocation; Farms/Ranches; Golf; International Buyers; LGBTQ+ Friendly; Listing Specialist; New Homes; Residential Investments; Residential Lots; Resort/Vacation; Senior; Townhomes/Condos; Trustee Sales; Waterfront/Waterview;

What do Clients Say?

We could not be happier with choosing Payton as our realtor. We are first time home buyers and Payton came highly recommend to us! Payton is knowledgeable, responsive and a go getter in this field. She made herself available to us 24/7 and we always felt like a priority to her. She is very professional, punctual and down to earth. Her dad, Todd, was there for most of the process as well and he gave us a lot of insight and advice. We truly felt like family to them with the way they carried themselves and treated us. We can’t say enough good things about this team!

Mike & Ciara Wood

Payton is an amazing Realtor. She made the process easy and stress free. She answered all of my questions quickly and gave 110% effort to find my perfect property. I will highly recommend her to anyone looking for their dream home or Real Estate investment. As I continue buying properties, I would definitely use Payton again!

Reed Hafeman

This was our 6th property purchase; we’ve worked with MANY real estate agents. It will be Payton going forward! She is absolutely everything an agent should be, we couldn’t be happier. She personally and directly sends properties that meet our exact specifications (not just signing us up for a generic range of things in Paragon). As soon as there were changes to the market, she let us know, and created our offer while ON VACATION in a super quick turnaround that got us the property. She’s responsive, professional, knowledgeable, and genuine. Highly, highly recommend.

Becky Frampton

Payton was great to work with. This was our fourth home purchase and our first investment property purchase. Payton was responsive and provided good insight into market conditions. We had a hiccup with our lender's closing process and Payton went above and beyond to help get the deal to closing at the last minute.

Joseph Bauer

Megan Huth 1 review • 0 photos starstarstarstarstar 50 weeks ago Where do we start with Payton! As first time home buyers, Payton was there for us every step of the way - guiding my boyfriend and I through this new adventure. She was so quick to respond to any question we had, proactive, knowledgeable, and attentive to detail. She knew exactly what we wanted. Lastly, she made the house buying process FUN and EASY! We are so thankful for her help. She was a key to our new chapter. Thank you, Payton!

Megan Huth

About Payton

I was born and raised right here in Appleton, WI, and still call it home. Growing up, real estate was always a part of my life. My parents are successful real estate investors who have been in the business for 25+ years. Though I initially pursued a different path, my passion for real estate prevailed when I purchased my first property in the beginning of 2022. This also happened to be my first investment property. I worked countless hours renovating it, contacting contractors, etc. My unique blend of investment expertise, local market knowledge, and extensive network allows me to provide exceptional service to buyers, sellers, investors, and first-time homebuyers alike. I believe everyone deserves the best representation and guidance during one of life's biggest decisions. With an open, honest approach, I strive to exceed expectations and make the experience positive and enjoyable. My goal is to understand your desires and achieve the outcome you envision. Contact me today – I'd love to help you find your dream home! - Payton Krueger